This website is no longer actively maintained
Some material and features may be unavailable
Perspectives

December 11, 2008
Mexico considers decriminalizing some drugs

 

A girl lights a candle during a protest against violence in Mexico.

Drug violence has taken a toll on Mexico, and drug-related killing more than doubled this year compared to 2007.

In October, President Felipe Calderón issued a proposal to decriminalize possession of small amounts of cocaine and other drugs in an effort to more efficiently target large-scale perpetrators.

Kathleen Blake Bohne writes at OpenDemocracy about the legalization debate in Mexico.

Drug decriminalisation in Mexico

[…]As this situation becomes more desperate, citizens and policymakers are left wondering where else to turn. […] On October 2, [President Felipe Calderón] proposed an additional tactic, presenting a drug legalization scheme to the Mexican Congress, where various members of all three main political parties support its passage. Legalization is the term being used to describe this proposal, however, it would be more accurate to describe it as decriminalization – it would offer the alternative of treatment rather than prosecution for possession of small amounts of marijuana, heroin, cocaine and methamphetamines. The stated goal is to help unclog the judicial system – already sluggish from corruption and poor infrastructure – overloaded with cases against addicts, whom many believe should be treated as patients rather than criminals. This should also free up law enforcement to concentrate its efforts against dealers; the same proposal includes tougher penalties on those who sell drugs to minors, for example.

The Mexican Congress passed a similar legalization proposal presented by then-President Vicente Fox in 2006, but Fox himself vetoed it, raising suspicions that U.S. pressure had been applied. But the 2008 proposal has already been given a quiet nod of approval by the U.S. drug czar, John Walters, who also assured his country’s unwavering support for Calderón’s military crackdown. This about-face on legalization – which Walters has been vehemently opposed to in the U.S – is likely because it is seen as a local effort that can be encouraged, as long as the overall government strategy remains adamantly hawkish on the drug war. It also appears that the momentum towards at least partial decriminalization in the region may be overwhelming; as noted in a recent report from the Center on Hemispheric Affairs, Latin America is shifting towards a “more independent, region-centric approach to the issue of the economics of narcotics.”

A rising tide of similar legislation is being considered in Brazil, Argentina, Venezuela and Bolivia, and in an October OAS (Organization of American States) meeting, the President of Honduras stated that “the trade of drugs, arms and people…are scourges on the international economy, and we are unable to provide effective responses” because of ongoing drug prohibition. The speaker of Mexico City’s legislative assembly, PRD Senator Victor Hugo Cirigo has even suggested the legalization of the sale of small amounts of marijuana in the capital city, citing the fact that marijuana is a “soft” drug, and that it is obvious that a new strategy is needed – he advised it is time to “hit criminals where it hurts: their finances.” Even the great Fuentes has lent his voice in support: “The only way to curb the violence of the drug cartels in Mexico is by legalizing drugs…If six or seven countries agreed with each other to legalize drug-taking, we would end it with the drug traffickers.” Fuentes’s statement highlights the significance of an international consensus on legalization; without a doubt, the United States, as the most profitable drug market in the hemisphere, would need to participate in order to reduce the cartels’ spoils of prohibition.

Legalization/decriminalization is certainly not the solution favored by everyone, including a very vocal and indignant Catholic Church, which criticized the legislators responsible for their “lack of moral values and ethics…thinking this makes them more modern.” Many fear a dramatic increase in the number of addicts, although they have been multiplying in Mexico for the past decade. Mexican drug use has spiked up 52% since 2000, with cocaine use alone increasing 100% in the past six years; women’s use has almost doubled in the same period. In a country where close to 50% of the population is under the age of 25 (the fastest growing demographic for drug addiction is the 12-17 year-old group), and rapid urbanization has created vast, destitute slums, it seems a sad truth that drug use will only increase, whether or not addicts are jailed.

In considering this issue, it should be remembered that even the few successes in the panorama of failures in the war on drugs have been mostly accidental. The end of the crack cocaine epidemic that gripped cities across the United States in the 1980s and early 90s was one of them. This triumph over a specific, highly potent drug and its users and dealers was credited with single-handedly reducing crime on city streets. How was this enviable feat accomplished? The truth is, no one knows.

To read more, see the original post.

The views expressed by contributing bloggers do not reflect the views of Worldfocus or its partners.

Photo courtesy of flickr user edcarsi under a Creative Commons license.

bookmark    print

Comments

5 comments

#5

There is a solution to this problem. Prosecute Drug pushers to the full extent of the Law. Drug users should be rehabilitated. Drug Pushers should get prison time. Legalization\decriminalization is a last resort method of response. Drug Education and disassociation from negative aspects in our culture could help a bunch. Blowing a blunt is considered cool thing to do to young people..why? because of evil influence from RAP counter culture and the crap that is on the TV. It started with the hippy’s influencing people with free love and drugs and Timothy Leary..Bunch of freakin idiots! People of the United states need to get it together and give the drugs a rest. Mexico’s President is right when he says the problem is the USA’s demand for illegal drugs is causing all the violence and Murder in Mexico.

#4

The legalization of Drugs in Mexico or the US could decrease the drug problem we face in Mexico’s northern boarders, but what about other countries? Colombia and Mexico traffic mostly cocaine and heroin; marijuana is mostly domestic and honestly unimportant to these drug cartels. The legalization of drugs in Mexico could cause a more violent Colombia since the drugs there would remain illegal.

#3

Everytime I hear about drug crimes, I feel myself as if I was living at the time of the prohibition. At that time it was alcohol.
I am for legalizing any kind of drug because
I trust in the human being and I respect their decisions. If they want to ruin their life, it is their business, neither mine not the government’s.
I agree that the US, as one of the main markets if not the largest, has to be the first to make the decision.
– I want the drugs dealers to conduct regular businesses, which means that they pay all taxes due to society: income tax, sales tax, employment etc..
-Those taxes would bring a lot of money for our budgets
-The price of drugs would certainly plummet, that would discourage the producters and middle men
-It would reduce the incentives to kill for a not anymore lucrative business.
-If it is now permitted, there is no more thrill for our teenagers to “do drugs”
I also know that in our wonderful US society so full of taboos, loosening the rules is not part of the agenda. Too bad, then, we’ll have to continue hearing about crimes for a buck and overloaded jails… and fear for our youth.

#2

While many mexican citizens will begin urge there representatives to end the war on drugs by ending prohibition, that will never happen. There is too much money being made on both sides of the boarder off the war on drugs. Like most worthless government programs, the war on drugs will never end. Get used to it.

#1

NOTHING will improve in Mexico until the United States eliminates its’ demand for illegal marijuana. There is only ONE way to do this: END the federal marijuana prohibition and license reputable businesses to produce and sell marijuana.

This one policy change will strip the Cartels of their customers and eliminate their need to commit murders to protect their drug incomes.

Until we do this we are as guilty as the Cartels for these murders!

Facebook Twitter YouTube
TAGS

Produced by Creative News Group LLC     ©2019 WNET.ORG     All rights reserved

Distributed by American Public Television